Survival of the fittest

Bob van Marlen, IMARES

Work is in progress at ICES to define methods for estimating discard survival in reference to the new European Commission Common Fisheries Policy. The ICES newsletter states, “Under the recently reformed European Commission Common Fisheries Policy (CFP), the practice of discarding fish will be phased out, replaced instead with landing obligations. Under the landing obligation, all catches of regulated species must be landed and counted against quotas unless it has been scientifically proven that the species can survive the discarding process. Species that display a high level of discard survivability will be awarded an exemption, meaning that fishers can return these fish to the sea. Unregulated and protected species will continue to be released.”

The ICES WKMEDS focuses on developing guidelines and identifying best practice for undertaking experiments to investigate the survival of organisms discarded from the catches of commercial fisheries. 

Importantly ICES states, “Techniques for estimating survival under review include captive observation, vitality assessment, and tagging and biotelemetry, each with its own advantages and disadvantages. By using a combination of techniques, as WKMEDS suggests, clear synergies can be achieved and challenges overcome.”

"It's an exciting time", state the workshop Chairs Michael Breen and Tom Catchpole, "this group will be central to an international community that are working together to address the important issue of discard survival."

The WKMEDS group is producing a synthesis of previous discard survival and mortality research with the goal to develop an integrated approach for estimating discard survival. The integrated approach is designed to guide scientists and managers in their evaluation of potential candidate fisheries and species for discarding exceptions to the landing obligation of the CFP. The integrated approach incorporates information about the role of fishing conditions as stressors, species sensitivity to stressors, vitality impairment of captured species, estimated discard survival rates, and cost-benefit analysis of methods for survival assessment in fisheries as well as impacts of discarding on fisheries stocks.